Pickled herring was born along the coasts of Scandinavia and Northern Europe as a winter preservation method, yet Central and Eastern European Jews warmly adopted it for centuries, turning it into the centerpiece of the festive table. Growing up in the 1960s, it was the undisputed star of Saturday Shabbat kiddushes at the synagogue, bar mitzvahs, and family celebrations. Back then, delicate matjes herring was my favorite, though over the years I was won over by the firmer, meatier style of pickled herring.
For years, vegan versions relied mostly on eggplant, but once you discover what happens when you swap it for oyster mushrooms in my home kitchen lab version, there is no going back. Unlike eggplant, which tends to turn soft and mushy, oyster mushrooms have a natural fibrous structure that remarkably mimics the bite and elasticity of real meaty herring. The secret lies in a brief, gentle cooking technique that preserves the mushroom's firmness without over-softening it, followed by marinating in a classic brine of red onion, allspice, bay leaves, and fresh dill. The result is an umami-rich homemade delicacy that pairs wonderfully with a crisp cracker or a slice of dark rye bread.

Recipe Architecture: Why It Works
To achieve the exact texture of meaty pickled herring without using fish, each step in this recipe solves a specific structural challenge:
Uniform cutting for the perfect bite.
Oyster mushrooms have a noticeable density difference between the cap and the stem. Separating the stems and halving them lengthwise (along with halving larger caps) creates uniform pieces that mimic the lengthwise grain of a fish fillet, ensuring every bite has the exact same texture.
Brief 5 to 6-minute steaming. Boiling in water or frying breaks down the mushroom's cell walls, causing it to lose shape or absorb heavy oil. A short steam over a pot of boiling water (using a simple mesh strainer and a lid, no special equipment needed) softens the raw stiffness and makes the mushroom flexible and elastic.
Warm brining to open the fibers. As soon as the mushrooms come out of the steamer while still piping hot, their pores are open. Transferring them immediately into a bowl with dill pickle brine (homemade is best), apple cider vinegar, and nori strips allows them to absorb the acidity, salinity, and subtle sea aroma deep into their core as they cool.

Creamy emulsion and fridge maturation. Combining a neutral oil (such as grapeseed or sunflower oil), unsweetened oat milk, and vegan mayo creates a rich, stable emulsion. Tossing the mushrooms and spices with the emulsion in a bowl ensures an even coating from every angle before transferring to an airtight container. After 24 hours in the refrigerator (flipping the container occasionally), the fat coats the softened fibers, the red onion mellows and releases its natural sweetness, and you get a silky, rich, and remarkably chewy texture.

Enjoy every bite 😋❣💫

RECIPE
Vegan Oyster Mushroom HerringFor the Mushroom Base
- 1 package fresh oyster mushrooms including the stems
For the Warm Brine
- ½ cup dill pickle brine preferably homemade
- 3 tablespoon quality apple cider vinegar
- 3 sheets nori seaweed folded into quarters and snipped into thin, short strips
- ½-¾ teaspoon fine sea salt
For the Emulsion & Seasoning
- ⅓ cup grapeseed oil or sunflower oil neutral oil
- ¼ cup unsweetened oat milk
- 2 tablespoon vegan mayonnaise
- 1 medium red onion sliced into paper-thin half-moons
- 1 teaspoon whole allspice berries
- 2 dried bay leaves
- ½ teaspoon coarsely ground black pepper
- 1 pinch granulated sugar to balance the acidity
for serving
- Fresh dill sprigs or chopped dill
- Cut the mushrooms. Separate the stems from the oyster mushroom caps and slice each stem lengthwise in half. If any caps are large, halve them as well to create uniform pieces that mimic the grain of a fish fillet.
- Steam briefly. Bring a small amount of water to a boil in a pot, place a wire mesh strainer (or steamer basket) over the pot, and arrange the mushrooms inside. Cover with a tight-fitting lid and steam for 5 to 6 minutes only, until the mushrooms become flexible and elastic while remaining firm.

- Warm brine. Transfer the mushrooms to a bowl immediately while still hot. Pour the pickle brine, apple cider vinegar, sea salt, and nori strips over them. Toss gently and let cool in the warm liquid for about 20 minutes so the mushrooms absorb the flavors into their core.
- Make the emulsion and toss. In a small bowl, whisk together the grapeseed oil, oat milk, and vegan mayonnaise until smooth and emulsified. Partially drain the mushrooms from the brine (keeping the nori strips clinging to them along with 1 to 2 tablespoons of the brine) and return them to the bowl. Add the red onion, allspice berries, bay leaves, black pepper, sugar, and the creamy emulsion. Gently toss by hand until every piece is thoroughly coated.
- Chill and serve. Transfer the mixture to an airtight container and refrigerate for at least 24 hours, flipping the container two or three times during chilling to keep the coating even. Serve cold on crisp crackers or dark rye bread topped with fresh dill.

















Leave a Reply